Roth vs Traditional IRA’s: A Video Discussion

Roth vs Traditional IRA’s

Roth and Traditional Ira’s-a topic of a great deal of discussion.  I have written previously about these differences in a recent Investing 101 post.

This subject is still “greek” to a lot of folks, if my discussion with my nurse friends is any indication.

Comments like, “What the hell were you talking about-I didn’t understand a word you were saying!”  Or, “you lost me when you started discussing the different stock   indexes like the Russell 2000, what the heck is that?  Is that similar to a Jack Russell Terrier or something??????

So my goal is to continue to break these investments issues into small segments, and allow things to sink in.

As I was taught by the senior residents, when I was an intern-Practice, Practice, Practice-we are only letting you admit every patient for the next 72 hours, because we are here to help you learn!!!

So I taped this video, the same day I taped the one about  opening a local brokerage account, at a bricks and mortar office-something that intimidates a lot of folks.

In this video today, Hal, a registered broker is discussing a few of the differences between Roth IRA’s and Traditional IRA’s.

Take Home Points in  the Roth/Traditional IRA decision tree:

  • Both are better than neither.
  • They offer a way to put away more money for retirement, than you might be able to put into your work IRA
  • They are more in your control than your 401-K or similar work accounts-the choice of investments is almost endless!
  • The Roth IRA is more limited by income as to who is eligible
  • The Roth is usually considered non-deductible but is tax free on withdrawal
  • The traditional IRA is a tax deduction for most eligible folks but is taxed  on withdrawal.
  • But as I said in the first bullet point-either one is better than nothing!!!

If you have any questions, please feel free to let me know.

I will do a  few posts soon-interviewing a CPA-with their  thoughts on these issues from a tax standpoint.  As  soon as they get over tax season-Tax season to a CPA is much like Christmas shopping season to a retailer, it is good for the bottom line, but heck on your Family Life!!!!

Thanks again to Hal, and Julie at Warren and Brannen Inc. for their assistance.

Tags: , , ,

2 Responses to “Roth vs Traditional IRA’s: A Video Discussion”

  1. Len Penzo says:

    Thanks for the article! This is very timely for me as I am currently planning to open up my first non-401(k) retirement account. I appreciate these primers comparing and contrasting each.

    Right now I am leaning towards the Roth, as I think its withdrawal rules with respect to taxes complements the 401(k) nicely.

    All the best,

    Len
    Len Penzo dot Com

    • Dr.Dean says:

      Thanks for stopping by Len.

      I agree, if I was starting from scratch with a new plan I would certainly start with the Roth. But everyone’s tax situation is different. So you have to do your homework, or ask you tax adviser.

Leave a Reply