Restaurant Tabs
A reader asks,
“I have in-laws that insist on going out to eat when they come to visit. We usually eat in-to save money, and to eat more healthy. They usually offer to pay, but I know they can’t afford it. We then end up fighting over the check!
What is the best way to deal with this?”
I have been in this situation numerous times during my long, stellar in-law career (I’ve been married 30 years….) Luckily I have only had to break in one set of in-laws… Well, let me re-think that. My wife’s Dad died when my wife and I had been married about 6 years, and her Mom remarried several years later. So I have had to break in aaaa new step-dad in-law?
Eating Out: Who Pays?
Many families struggle with the eating out and who pays dilemma.
There can be so many family dynamics going on:
- The I am the proud father and I will always pay!
- The I am always the moocher, and will never pay. (but I do luv lobster-Surf and Turf is my middle name…)
- The If you are picking up the bill, I will only order saltines, and the soup of the day (“man, this is expensive!” gets whispered behind the menus…)
The dilemma:
Unfortunately it can be a lose/lose at times. You don’t want to seem a cheap skate, (you prefer the term frugal thank you). And by going out, you may be spending money neither family has. But only one of you has figured this out….
How I do it:
My side of the family has never really had an issue with this. We either split the bill per couple (there are 5 of us siblings) or one of us volunteers to pick up the tab. Nobody keeps score. We just say thank you and move on.
My wife’s family has had issues with this. They never want to be “beholden” in southern-speak.
We have, over time, decided to deal with it this way in our household:
- If we have already prepared a meal, we gently insist that we eat at home. “The meal is prepared and we don’t want it to go to waste” usually works.
- We also offer an alternative. We eat here tonight, then if you want to go out tomorrow for lunch… or something similar.
- If they make what seems to be a genuine offer to pick up the tab, my wife has learned to let it go, and just say thank you.
- We always politely offer to pick up the tab or to split it first.
Why:
- Although you may know YOUR in-laws don’t make financially sound decisions, making the judgment that they can’t afford the tab is not your job. You are forcing your values regarding money on them.
- Saying a gracious thank you rather than arguing over a check can be learned. I think it is a sign of financial and emotional maturity.
Reader Questions:
What do you and your family do regarding eating out when you have company, especially family?
How do you then deal with the check? Do you fight over it? Is it a source of stress in the family?
(photo credit whologwhy c.c.)
Check out The Carnival of Money Stories at Squirrelers! I am honored to have been included.
Remember: the RSS feed is up on the top right, please sign up and have The Millionaire Nurse delivered each time there is a new post! And follow @DrDeanBurke, and Like/Tweet/Stumble’s are appreciated! I make it easy with short cut tabs on the right side….












